The walnut in our backyard is mostly bare now. A few patches of yellow leaves are hanging on, darker than they were a week ago, and this morning the sun caught the branching against a blue sky with clouds low on the horizon. I stood on a side of the trunk where I don’t usually stand and shifted my weight from one leg to the other, following the light across the bark. There’s a lighter patch there that I’ve seen before. I still don’t know how it formed. It could be an old branch scar, an injury or something else in the tree’s growing. Looking closer gave me a better question and no history.
That’s a fair picture of where my doctoral work is this fall. I’ve been out beside this tree most mornings since early September, talking into a recorder about what I notice and then writing it up. The practice began as the field journal for my second comprehensive exam at CIIS. It’s become the place where the argument gets made, and where it gets corrected.
What the Exam Is
Comps 2 is the second of two comprehensive exams in the Ecology, Spirituality, and Religion program. The first wrapped up over the summer and produced the long paper I posted here in August. This one is tighter and faces the dissertation. The reading runs through Husserl’s Ideas II, Edith Stein on empathy and living form, Merleau-Ponty‘s late writing on flesh, Raymond Ruyer, Gregory Bateson and Vanessa Watts, with a theological shelf for the Ecology of the Cross: Gregersen, Moltmann, Maximus the Confessor, Melanie Harris and LeRhonda Manigault-Bryant among them. The paper is due in mid-December.
The field notes are public at ecologicalintentionality.org, one entry for each morning’s sit, with the corrections left in. Three working essays went up there this past week: What Flesh Explains, How a Purpose Takes Shape and A Life of Its Own. They set what I’m seeing in the yard beside the people who’ve already explained a good deal of it.
The whole record is also kept in a public GitHub repository. The open questions are tracked there as issues, with a research roadmap showing what’s been argued and what hasn’t, so anyone can see how a claim changed and why.
Why I’m Doing This in Public
Most scholarship shows up finished. I wanted to see what happens when the history of an argument can be inspected along with its conclusion. In late October I removed a broken piece of limb I took to be the walnut’s. In mid-November, with the leaves down, I could see it had come from the neighboring oak. The correction is in the record beside the mistake, and a reader can see what changed and why.
That matters for this project in particular. I’m arguing that other lives can correct what we think we know about them, and it’d be strange to make that argument in a form that hides my own corrections. So the workflow is part of the method. It keeps what I encountered separate from what I inferred, it makes revisions visible, and it pushes back on me before a claim goes out.
It has limits, and I try to say so. The private journal stays private, and it’s messy. What’s public is a curated layer, which means I’m still choosing what crosses over. Other people share this yard and this work, and taking part in something isn’t the same as agreeing to be written about. Publishing a correction doesn’t make the corrected account right, either. What open research gives a reader is the chance to check how I got here.
What Changed
I started the fall hoping the walnut would show me something about consciousness that Husserl had missed. It hasn’t, and by early November I’d quit asking it to. Husserl already accounts for habit, bodily ability and the way a practical purpose gets its shape. Bateson already describes learning as something that runs through a wider circuit than one body. What I can defend is narrower, and I think it’s truer to what’s happened out there.
Here’s the case that carries most of it. The kids’ climbing dome stood near an exposed root of the walnut. It had seemed like a fine spot: shade, a swing, room to play. On November 8 I noticed the root and wondered whether the dome belonged there. Three mornings later I dragged it about ten feet away. That part was done in a few minutes. Whether the root is any better off is something only the tree’s next seasons can show, and I haven’t measured anything.
Where the dome had been, there was a ring of low green plants around a bare center worn down by small feet. I’d seen those plants for two years. I’d mowed around them on purpose, partly because the children wanted them kept. And in all my thinking about the move, I never once asked what would happen to them when the dome was gone. My care was pointed at the root, and it decided what I looked past. I’ve committed to leaving the ring alone through winter.
So the claim I’m carrying into the paper has three parts. A relationship with another living thing can form what I’m able to notice and do. A particular encounter can give a purpose its specifics, down to how I move when I’m cutting bamboo next to plants I don’t want to hurt. And whether the purpose is fulfilled depends on a life that keeps going after I’ve put the tools away. Those three can come apart. I can be well formed and still judge badly, or judge well and still not help.
The Cross
The theological half of the project is the Ecology of the Cross, and this week it’s been running through Colossians 1:15–20. Verse 16 says all things were created through Christ and for him: τὰ πάντα διʼ αὐτοῦ καὶ εἰς αὐτὸν ἔκτισται (κτίζω, to create). Verse 20 uses the same εἰς αὐτόν for reconciliation, ἀποκαταλλάξαι τὰ πάντα εἰς αὐτόν (ἀποκαταλλάσσω, to reconcile), and says peace is made through the blood of the cross: εἰρηνοποιήσας διὰ τοῦ αἵματος τοῦ σταυροῦ αὐτοῦ (εἰρηνοποιέω, to make peace). I read that as saying the creatures around a congregation matter before the congregation finds a use for them, and that reconciliation has a cost the text doesn’t hide.
What I’m arguing is that participation in Christ can form what a community wants and what it’s willing to carry. That has an edge to it. A community can’t call another creature’s injury its own self-giving. If a church project asks something of the soil, the roots, the neighbors or the volunteers, the cross is a reason to ask who’s actually paying.
I’ve got a small test case coming. I’ve floated the idea of a garden at church, and it’s only an idea. Other ideas for that ground already exist, and people who’ve tended it know things I don’t. Vanessa Watts’s work on Place-Thought has pushed me to start with what’s already living and owed in a place before deciding what I’d like to do with it.
What’s Next
I’m writing toward a full statement of the argument by November 30 and the exam paper by mid-December. After that comes the dissertation prospectus.
Plenty is unfinished. I haven’t read all of the Maximus, Moltmann, Harris or Manigault-Bryant I’ve promised to read, and I’d rather say so than cite past what I know. The stronger idea I started with, that another organism’s ongoing life takes part in consciousness itself, is still an open question and may stay one. And I don’t know whether moving the dome did the walnut any good.
What I do know is that the ring of plants is still there, the bark has a pale patch I can’t explain, and I’ll be back out in the morning.
As always, the daily field notes and working essays are at ecologicalintentionality.org. The research record, roadmap, and open questions are on GitHub.