Beyond Technocracy: Embracing an Ecological Metaphysics of Communion

Republican Budget Bill Aims to End I.R.A. Clean Energy Boom – The New York Times:

Over the past three years, companies have made plans to invest more than $843 billion across the United States in projects aimed at reducing planet-warming emissions, driven by lucrative tax credits for clean energy provided by the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act.

But only about $321 billion of that money has actually been spent, with many projects still on the drawing board, according to data made public on Tuesday by the Clean Investment Monitor, a joint project of the Rhodium Group and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Now, much of the rest, about $522 billion, will depend on action playing out on Capitol Hill. Starting on Tuesday, Republicans in Congress will begin a contentious debate over proposals to roll back tax credits for low-carbon energy as they search for ways to pay for a roughly $4 trillion tax cut package favored by President Trump.

Recent political debates, such as those surrounding the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), highlight a troubling reliance on technocratic solutions to address the climate crisis. While investments in clean energy are essential, they are insufficient without a deeper transformation in our collective consciousness and ethical frameworks.

The IRA represents a substantial federal investment in clean energy, aiming to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and promote the development of renewable energy sources. However, as political dynamics shift, the stability and longevity of such initiatives come into question.

For instance, recent legislative proposals have sought to roll back key provisions of the IRA, including clean energy tax credits. These political maneuvers highlight the fragility of technocratic solutions that rely on shifting political will.

Addressing the climate crisis requires more than policy changes; it demands a fundamental shift in how we perceive our relationship with the natural world. Philosophers like Catherine Pickstock and William Desmond advocate for a return to liturgical language and metaphysical frameworks that emphasize communion and participation with the environment.

Pickstock argues that true language is inherently liturgical, fostering a participatory relationship with reality. Desmond’s concept of the “metaxological” emphasizes the importance of the “between”—the relational space that enables genuine connection and ethical engagement with others, including the non-human world.

By embracing liturgical practices and ecological ethics, we can cultivate a sense of reverence and responsibility toward the environment. This approach moves beyond viewing nature as a resource to be managed and instead recognizes it as a sacred community to which we belong.

Such a transformation encourages practices that are sustainable not only environmentally but also spiritually and culturally. It fosters communities that are attuned to the rhythms of nature and committed to the well-being of all life forms.

While technocratic solutions like the IRA play a role in mitigating climate change, they are insufficient on their own. Lasting change arises from a profound transformation in consciousness, one that reestablishes our connection to the natural world through liturgy, language, and ethical living. Only by addressing the metaphysical and psychological roots of our ecological crisis can we hope to create a sustainable and harmonious future.

Thinking Religion 169: The Theology of Trees

Here’s the new episode of the next season of my Thinking Religion podcast. This season is titled Rooted in Mystery: The Rewilding of Thinking Religion.

It’s a short episode, and this season will have a few longer episodes as I unpack some of the ideas I’ve been working on in the braids that combine theology, ecology, intentionality, faith, family, and life.

But let’s start with this one and this question… What would change if you believed the world was watching you with love?

“We need so much less than we take and we owe so much more than we give.”

I often get asked why I always use squirrels as my mascot and avatar as a teacher. Here’s a good reason why. Andrea Gibson’s work is so important and needed in times like these. Worth your four minutes to watch (and re-watch)…

Reflecting on Brazil’s Wildfires and Drought

The record-breaking wildfires and persistent droughts in Brazil are urgent reminders of our need to rethink how we relate to the natural world. These ecological crises highlight the consequences of viewing nature merely as a resource for human use, rather than as a dynamic participant in a sacred web of life. The concept of ecological intentionality calls us to recognize the agency of non-human elements—like forests, rivers, and climate patterns—and to foster a more intentional relationship with our ecosystems.

Theological Reflections on Ecological Crisis

From a biblical perspective, the notion of ecological intentionality aligns closely with scriptures that emphasize humanity’s role as caretakers of creation. In Psalm 24:1, we read, “The Earth is the Lord’s and everything in it,” suggesting that our stewardship is meant to be characterized by respect and reverence, not domination. Likewise, Genesis’ account of Noah’s Ark reflects God’s concern for the preservation of all species, underscoring biodiversity as a divine priority. The fires and droughts in Brazil challenge us to reexamine our faithfulness to this sacred duty.

Isaiah 24:4-5 poignantly describes a land that “mourns and withers…because they have broken the everlasting covenant,” reminding us that our ecological crises are, at their core, spiritual crises. The Earth, groaning in Romans 8:22, is a plea for healing and renewal—a call for humanity to restore right relationships with creation. Brazil’s environmental disasters amplify these biblical calls to action, pushing us to consider how our theology can contribute to ecological reconciliation.

Integrating Indigenous Wisdom

Indigenous perspectives, like those of Ailton Krenak, a prominent indigenous leader and thinker from Brazil, provide critical insights into this conversation. In his work “Ideas to Postpone the End of the World,” Krenak advocates for viewing the Earth not as a resource to exploit but as a living entity with which we are deeply interconnected. He critiques the dominant worldview that separates humanity from nature and calls for a return to a spiritual relationship that honors the Earth’s inherent value and vitality.

Krenak’s perspectives complement the biblical teachings of stewardship and care, offering a vision of ecological intentionality that is inclusive of diverse spiritual understandings. His call to recognize the sacred interdependence of all life resonates deeply with the idea that we must foster a participatory awareness, where both human and non-human elements are seen as co-creators in the ongoing story of creation.

Humans only talk about human rights, and environmental law is anthropocentric, it has no interest in whether the forest will die, the river will be polluted.

– Ailton Krenak

A Call to Action: Toward Ecological Reconciliation

Ecological intentionality challenges us not only to reflect but to act. We are called to cultivate practices that acknowledge our profound interdependence with the natural world, such as supporting sustainable policies, engaging in mindful consumption, and embracing indigenous stewardship methods. Beyond practical actions, we must cultivate spiritual disciplines that honor this interconnectedness—whether through prayer, community worship that integrates environmental concerns, or personal practices that express gratitude for creation.

Colonial thinking is powerful because it uses instruments such as economics, which globally institutes the possession of things and land. It is associated with the appropriation of technologies that accelerate extractivism in ecosystems, oceans, mountains and deserts

– Ailton Krenak

Reimagining Our Relationship with Creation

The wildfires and droughts in Brazil are a clarion call for deeper spiritual and theological engagement with our ecological reality. By integrating biblical insights with indigenous wisdom, like that of Ailton Krenak, we can move toward a more holistic understanding of our role in the divine community of life. Ecological intentionality invites us to reimagine our relationship with creation, recognizing that the health of our spirits is inseparably linked to the health of the Earth.

May we heed this call with urgency, wisdom, and humility, living in ways that honor all that God has made, and recognizing that we are not separate from, but deeply connected to, the entire web of life.

Embracing Ecological Intentionality: A New Lens for Faith and Community in South Carolina

As I continue my PhD studies in Ecology, Spirituality, and Religion at the California Institute of Integral Studies (CIIS), I find myself reflecting on what it means to live intentionally with the natural world — especially in a place like South Carolina, where the landscapes and ecosystems are so deeply intertwined with our history and identity. After 15 years of teaching in the Carolinas, and now in a new chapter focused on ministry, writing, and research, I’m more convinced than ever that we need a fresh perspective to navigate our relationship with the environment. One concept that has emerged as particularly compelling for me is what I’m calling “Ecological Intentionality.”

What is Ecological Intentionality?

Ecological Intentionality is about consciously engaging with the natural world in a way that acknowledges its inherent value, complexity, and spiritual significance. It’s not just about recognizing the environment as a resource to be managed, but rather seeing it as a dynamic partner in our shared existence. This idea grows out of my work in phenomenology — the study of how we experience and perceive the world — and challenges us to think beyond the human-centered perspectives that often dominate our thinking about ecology.

In South Carolina, where the coastlines, forests, rivers, and wetlands all hold rich stories and deep cultural significance, Ecological Intentionality takes on a special meaning. It calls us to awaken to the ways in which our lives are entangled with the land and to the spiritual lessons that our environment offers if we choose to listen. The ancient oaks in the Lowcountry, the flowing waters of the Congaree, and even the changing seasons across the Piedmont remind us of the intricate connections between all living things.

Ecological Intentionality in Faith Communities

In my ministry in the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship, I’ve witnessed how faith communities can play a transformative role in rethinking our relationship with the environment. We live in a time when environmental crises are both immediate and overwhelming — from the hurricanes that batter our coastlines to the slower, less visible changes like the warming of our waters and the loss of biodiversity in our forests.

Ecological Intentionality offers a new lens through which faith communities can approach these challenges. It moves beyond the idea of stewardship as mere responsibility and invites us to see our relationship with the Earth as a profound spiritual practice. It’s about cultivating a deeper awareness of the sacredness of all creation and recognizing our interconnectedness with every part of it—not just as caretakers but as co-inhabitants of a shared space.

Bringing Phenomenology into Ecological Conversations

This concept also intersects with my studies at CIIS, where I am exploring how phenomenological approaches can inform contemporary theological understandings of ecology. Phenomenology, mainly as developed by thinkers like Edmund Husserl, emphasizes the importance of direct experience and consciousness in shaping how we perceive the world. It suggests that by intentionally focusing on our lived experiences with the natural world — by noticing the texture of the soil, the sound of the wind through the trees, the way light filters through a canopy — we can come to a more profound understanding of our place within it.

This approach is particularly relevant in South Carolina. Our state’s landscapes have been shaped by centuries of human interaction, from the agricultural practices of the Indigenous peoples and enslaved Africans who cultivated the rice fields of the Lowcountry to the modern-day tensions between development and conservation. Ecological Intentionality encourages us to engage these histories thoughtfully and to seek out the spiritual lessons that can be found in our everyday interactions with the environment.

A Call to Action for South Carolinians

While I may no longer be teaching in a traditional classroom, I still see education as a vital tool for awakening ecological awareness. Whether through sermons, workshops, or community dialogues, I want to encourage others to embrace Ecological Intentionality in their own lives. This concept is not just for academics or environmentalists; it’s for anyone who feels called to reconnect with the Earth meaningfully.

South Carolina, with its unique blend of natural beauty, history, and cultural diversity, offers a fertile ground for exploring these ideas. I believe we have an opportunity to lead the way in creating new models of community and spiritual life that honor the Earth as an integral part of our shared story. By adopting an intentional approach to how we live with our surroundings, we can begin to build a more just, sustainable, and spiritually enriched future for all.

A Priesthood of Pollution

Lots to ponder here about human consciousness, human angst, and the coming torrent of AI bots fueled by corporate profit at the expense of polluting the digital ecology we’ve built over the last few decades.

It is by no means currently pristine, but pollution always comes with capitalist initiatives, and AI bots are about to transform so much of what we know about everyday life, leaving behind much more artificial pollution than we can ponder now…

These AI agents are building ‘civilizations’ on Minecraft | Cybernews:

Run by California-based startup Altera, the project had AI agents collaborating to create virtual societies complete with their own governmental institutions, economy, culture, and religion.

Altera said it ran simulations on a Minecraft server entirely populated by autonomous AI agents “every day” and the results were “always different.”

In one simulation, AI agents banded together to set up a market, where they agreed to use gems as a common currency to trade supplies – building an economy.

Curiously, according to the company, it was not the merchants who traded the most but a corrupt priest who started bribing townsfolk to convert to his religion.

Good read on the topic with some predictions about AI bots from Ted Gioia here as well